I’m trying to understand how an app would even get that info in the first place, how that’s classified and why a mobile operating system even has a way to provide that data.

Am I correct in assuming that if an app is used without play store / play store framework that it would not be able to get access to that data?

Thanks!

  • cinabongo@lemmy.world
    1552·
    1 year ago

    From what I know having worked in adtech,

    • they collect as much information as they can from the device such as location from GPS, interests from follows, likes dwell time on posts, and other information you knowingly or unknowingly provide. This includes scraping information from photos and videos you upload to the app. Eg, you upload a picture of an expensive bag with the caption “my new bag” - the bag brand can be determined and assessed algorithmically.
    • the above extends to websites you visit with in-app browsers and the actions you take while on those pages
    • deduce what they can’t eg where you live & work based where you spend time during the day vs night,your real life interests based on places you visit eg gym, fast food places, church etc. Also they apply complex algorithms to relatively accurately deduce anything you don’t directly provide. Eg if you disable accurate location, they can figure it out based on the ip address(es) you connect to the app from (geolocation algorithms) .
    • and what they can’t deduce is bought from third parties. Those are companies normal people don’t know exist whose sole purpose is scraping and categorising information - sort of similar to credit agencies but different. In this case, they take what they know about you and send it to this third party which then returns eveything they have that’s related. Eg the app (threads) might send your email and username and get a response containing your previous home address (say scraped from some insecure government website)

    With the above, even without knowing your name (this can easily be determined) , they are able to know enough about you to determine the kind of person you are, with whom you interact, where you go, your political affiliations, job, salary estimate etc and sell it to advertisers. This is usually sold as “audiences” but given the tools provided to advertisers, it’s easy to create hyper targeted ads and recommendations (remember Cambridge Analytica).

    We voluntarily give up a lot more information than we realise.

    And remember, the smartest people on the planet work at these companies, so the above is nothing in comparison to what behemoths like Facebook, Google, Tencent, etc are capable of.

    • zlatiah@kbin.social
      261·
      1 year ago

      Second this!

      Phones give out a lot of personal information on their own lol. On top of the phone, don’t forget that social media apps like Threads also require you to login… with credentials stored at FB/Meta… that they can derive all the aforementioned information on, as well as other type of things (Amazon purchases? Stuff you watch on youtube.com? Google queries?..) by using some creative tracking technology. You basically gave them a dog tag to identify you whenever you sign up for services after all

      For shittier apps like Thread, apparently they also do some weird stuff like forcing the app to be on once the OS boots, so… yeah.

    • bricks@lemmy.world
      8·
      1 year ago

      This is a really good oversight (see: insight, overview, etc). Honestly, for anyone actually interested in this stuff and what makes the internet tracking/advertising machine tick, take some of the HubSpot Academy’s courses. There’s definitely other courses out there, but the HubSpot ones are all free, and the topics aren’t hard once you get immersed in it.

      Plus afterwards you can put the faux-certs on your resume and knife fight with the 20,000,000 other adtech people that just got laid off.

      • Drew Got No Clue@lemmy.world
        2·
        1 year ago

        Not a native speaker and kind of OT, but isn’t it supposed to be “overview” rather than “oversight” in this case? Maybe not necessarily “overview”, but I think “oversight” would only mean mistake or supervision. I was just wondering.

        • bricks@lemmy.world
          3·
          1 year ago

          Probably. I write half my comments drunk, so I wouldn’t use them as a basis for ESL learning 🙃

          It’s a good catch!! Apologies for any confusion.

    • desmondjones@lemmy.world
      7·
      1 year ago

      Don’t forget, giving these apps access to your photos also opens up a puzzle of location data of where you spend your time and have visited

    • I_Miss_Daniel@kbin.social
      3·
      1 year ago

      This sort of makes it tempting to run everything in an emulated virtual machine that is streamed to your phone…

      Each app in a separate instance…

    • Niello@kbin.social
      3·
      1 year ago

      Doesn’t Threads app have direct access to browsing history as well? I feel like that’s another can of worm that could probably use some further explanation on.